Telling a Father That He Committed a Sin | Sheilot

Telling a Father That He Committed a Sin

Question

Is it permissible for children to point out to their father that in the past, apparently, he offended the synagogue gabbai publicly? If the father is currently going through a difficult period in his life, should the children intervene or refrain from saying anything?

Answer

Hello and blessings 

It is forbidden for a son to say to his father, “You transgressed the words of the Torah.” 

It is permissible to tell stories in the father’s presence about people who hurt others and were punished, or about people who asked forgiveness and were helped. 

If the father asks on his own, “Is there something I need to correct?” it is permissible to answer him in a respectful manner: “Perhaps so-and-so was once hurt by you.” [They should not say, “You hurt so-and-so,” or, “You behaved toward him improperly.”] 

Certainly, the sons should try to help as much as they can to bring him out of his difficulty, with assistance, encouragement, and the like. But they should not “help” him by conducting his “soul-searching” for him...

Answered 20 October 2026 How answers are reviewed
Rabbi Israel Cohen
Answered by
Answers questions at Rav Amram Fried's Beit Horaah
Smicha "Yoreh-Yoreh" (2012), Rav Amram Fried's Beit Horaah
Orach Chaim, Yoreh Deah
About the Rabbi

Source

Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh De’ah, siman 240, se’if 11
If one saw his father transgress the words of the Torah, he should not say to him: “You transgressed the words of the Torah.” Rather, he should say to him: “Father, it is written in the Torah such-and-such,” as though he is asking him, and not warning him; and he will understand on his own and will not be embarrassed. 

Comments

Have an additional question on this topic or need clarification? Leave your comment below. (Please note that the comment will not be published but will be sent directly to the answering Rabbi for review and a private response)

Please sign up or log in to submit your comment