Bli neder after הדרן עלך?
Question
When saying הדרן ילך upon finishing a Masechet, must one add בלי נדר because it might be considered a form of a vow to learn the Masechet again? Or does הדרן עלך refer to the past i.e. the learning just completed?
Answer
Shalom!
Thank you for your question.
Some are stringent and say "bli neder", but in practice, there is no obligation for this, since one may rely (concerning this matter) on the declaration made Erev Rosh Hashanah.
There are other reasons brought why one doesn't need to say "Bli Neder" for example; the word “Hadran” in Aramaic means “we have come back to you” (as in Bava Basra 74b) and NOT “we WILL come back to you.” This is not a false statement because everyone learns the entire Torah in their mother’s womb, so no area of Torah is truly new. Another reason is some say that the “Hadran” passage is a prayer not a commitment.
Answered by
Author of the "Dalet Amot BeHalacha" series
Smicha Yoreh-Yoreh (1999) and Yadin-Yadin, author of "Dalet Amot BeHalacha" (11 volumes)
Orach Chaim, Yoreh Deah, Even HaEzer, Choshen Mishpat (excluding laws of interest)
About the Rabbi
Comments
Have an additional question on this topic or need clarification? Leave your comment below. (Please note that the comment will not be published but will be sent directly to the answering Rabbi for review and a private response)
Did you find the answer to your question?
Thank you!
Your answer has been received. It helps us make the search more accurate.
Opening the question form…
