Refund of brokerage fees after winning in the Mehir LaMishtaken program | Sheilot

Refund of brokerage fees after winning in the Mehir LaMishtaken program

Question

Hello.

A broker who concluded a contract for a client, and the client breached the contract because he won in the Mehir LaMishtaken program – does the broker have to return the brokerage fee?

Answer

Shalom u’vracha.

No, he is not required to return the brokerage fee.

Answered 10 February 2026 How answers are reviewed
Rabbi Israel Cohen
Answered by
Answers questions at Rav Amram Fried's Beit Horaah
Smicha "Yoreh-Yoreh" (2012), Rav Amram Fried's Beit Horaah
Orach Chaim, Yoreh Deah
About the Rabbi

Source

In Siman 185, se’if 10, regarding matchmaking fees (shadchanus), the Rema explains that the time customarily set for payment is also the time that creates the obligation to pay. Once matters have reached that stage, even if the arrangement later falls apart, the matchmaker does not have to return the money unless such a condition was explicitly stipulated. Although the poskim there disagree whether the engagement (erusin) already obligates payment even when the custom is to pay at the time of the wedding – since there are penalties for breaking off a shidduch, or perhaps those penalties are not considered benefit but only distress – nevertheless, it is certainly so with the signing of a contract: that is the time designated for payment, and it is what creates the obligation for the brokerage fee. If the contract is later cancelled, that is not connected to the contract that was signed earlier.

Comments

Have an additional question on this topic or need clarification? Leave your comment below. (Please note that the comment will not be published but will be sent directly to the answering Rabbi for review and a private response)

Please sign up or log in to submit your comment