Undertaking Tzedakah on a Condition Made in Thought | Sheilot

Undertaking Tzedakah on a Condition Made in Thought

Question

A person thought in his heart that if he would do a certain thing, he would give tzedakah. Is such a thought considered a tzedakah vow, or is it considered an asmachta and therefore not binding? It is important to emphasize: the matter was only in thought and was not stated verbally.

Answer

Shalom u'vrachah 

The exemption of asmachta does not apply to tzedakah. 

The poskim disagree as to whether there is an obligation through thought without speech. 

In practice: according to the Rema, he is obligated, and according to the Mechaber, he is exempt.

Answered 18 November 2026 How answers are reviewed
Rabbi Israel Cohen
Answered by
Answers questions at Rav Amram Fried's Beit Horaah
Smicha "Yoreh-Yoreh" (2012), Rav Amram Fried's Beit Horaah
Orach Chaim, Yoreh Deah
About the Rabbi

Source

Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh De'ah, siman 258, se'if 13 — a dispute regarding an obligation of tzedakah through thought. 

Ibid., se'if 10, and in Choshen Mishpat, siman 207, se'if 19 — that one is obligated in tzedakah even in the case of an asmachta. 

Comments

Have an additional question on this topic or need clarification? Leave your comment below. (Please note that the comment will not be published but will be sent directly to the answering Rabbi for review and a private response)

Please sign up or log in to submit your comment