Reading the Ten Commandments | Sheilot

Reading the Ten Commandments

Question

Why do some sources frown upon standing for the Ten Commandments?

Answer


 Shalom! 

 Thank you for your question. 

 It is true that some sources frown upon the custom of standing for certain special Torah readings. This is the famous view of the Rambam (along with others). 

 The reason for the opposition was due to the concern that it give the impression that some pats of the Torah are mor important than other parts of the Torah. This is, of course, untrue as every story, commandment, and even every word of the Torah is equally important. Indeed, a Torah missing even just one letter is not a kosher Torah no matter where that letter is missing. 

 Although some halachic authorities, allow standing for special Torah readings, especially for the reading of the Ten Commandments where were try to re-live the experience, and we are told that the Jewish people stood when the Torah was given. 

 One should follow the congregation custom: if the congregations stands then one should stand even if one normally follows the Rambam. And if the custom is to sit, one should sit regardless of one’s normal practice. 

Hagaon Harav Fried Shelita says, that if there is no specific custom, then one should sit.



Answered 22 May 2025 How answers are reviewed
Rabbi Ari Enkin
Answered by
Author of the "Dalet Amot BeHalacha" series
Smicha Yoreh-Yoreh (1999) and Yadin-Yadin, author of "Dalet Amot BeHalacha" (11 volumes)
Orach Chaim, Yoreh Deah, Even HaEzer, Choshen Mishpat (excluding laws of interest)
About the Rabbi

Comments

Have an additional question on this topic or need clarification? Leave your comment below. (Please note that the comment will not be published but will be sent directly to the answering Rabbi for review and a private response)

Please sign up or log in to submit your comment