Double Damage to a Rented Car
This question and answer were automatically translated using our trained AI and have not yet been reviewed by a qualified rabbi. Please treat this translation with caution.
go to original →
Question
Hello, I rented a car from a local rental company, and while reversing, the rear bumper of the car was slightly damaged by a post on the curb. The company told me that a few days ago another renter caused similar damage to the other side of the same bumper, but it has not yet been repaired, and they suggested charging both of us half each. [The repair cost is the same for one or two damages]. I am asking what is the Halachic opinion on this matter? And can the fact that the bumper was already damaged and due for repair exempt me from payment or part of it?
Answer
Hello
If the damage caused by the first person is typically repaired by most people, the first has already caused the damage, and the second is exempt.
However, if most people leave it as is, but the value of the car decreases, both parties responsible for the damage should each pay half for the replacement.