Studying the Talmud in Memory of the Victims of Simchat Torah
This question and answer were automatically translated using our trained AI and have not yet been reviewed by a qualified rabbi. Please treat this translation with caution.
go to original →
Question
In my synagogue, they decided to complete several tractates by Simchat Torah in memory of the victims, and they sold aliyot, etc., by pages, and with them, they complete the tractates. I bought 8 pages and filled five pages from the tractates that remained, but I had the opportunity to take another 3 pages because there were still pages left in those tractates. However, because those were difficult pages, I didn't take them and waited for a new tractate to open, where I would take the additional three pages I committed to. In the end, I didn't notice, and people already filled the tractates, and all the tractates were completed. My question is: Is it okay for me to take 3 random pages in the Talmud, and will it be considered that I fulfilled my commitment, as it is not in the same tractates for which they sold pages, etc., which are already completed? (I want to clarify that I asked the gabbai, and he told me that I can take the remaining three pages from wherever I want)?
Answer
Hello
Blessed are you for this wonderful initiative.
You can study any 3 pages you wish, and by doing so, you will fulfill your commitment.