Eating a limb from a live animal created through “Sefer Yetzirah”

Question

The Shlah (author of “Shnei Luchot ha-Brit”) writes that the brothers ate a limb of a living animal created through “Sefer Yetzirah”, and I am having difficulty understanding the difference between this and a regular animal. How do we know that it is permissible to eat a limb from a live animal created through “Sefer Yetzirah”? (This refers to the Rashi commentary to verse Genesis 37:2, in which Rashi states that Joseph told his father Jacob that he saw his brothers eat a limb of a living animal.)

Answer

Dear …!
Chacham Tzvi (Ch. 93) indeed discusses whether a being created through “Sefer Yetzirah” has the status of a human and the status of a Jew. However, his son (Divrei Rav Meshulam, Ch. 10) brings a handwritten note written by Chacham Tzvi himself, where he writes that after seeing in the works of the Ramak that a creature created through “Sefer Yetzirah” lacks “nefesh”, “ruach” and “neshamah” and only possesses simple vitality, it became obvious to him that it does not have the status of a human in any way, and by the same token, it lacks the status of an animal. And certainly, since it has no soul, there is no prohibition on eating a limb from a live animal, as this very prohibition is learned from the verse (Genesis 9:4) “Only flesh with the soul thereof, which is the blood thereof, shall ye not eat”.

Source

Chacham Tzvi (Ch. 93), Divrei Rav Meshulam (Ch. 10)

Comments

Have an additional question on this topic or need clarification? Leave your comment below. (Please note that the comment will not be published but will be sent directly to the answering Rabbi for review and a private response)

Please sign up or log in to submit your comment

Become our patrners in supporting and spreading the Torah
Help us answer more questions faster and better
Join the mission
More questions in this category